- 1956 – Pots of Money
- 1957 – Sit Down a Minute, Adrian | Home at Seven | But Once a Year
- 1958 – Thrice I Denied Him | Will Any Gentleman? | The Unhallowed Saint
- 1959 – He Saved Others | Off the Deep End | Here We Come Gathering
- 1960 – The Admirable Crichton | Quiet Weekend
- 1961 – The Choice | Tons of Money
- 1962 – The House of Baxter | The Holly and the Ivy
- 1963 – Green Grow the Cabbages | The Faith Hawker | The Trapper | The Gift
- 1964 – Doctor Fell
- 1965 – Running Riot
- 1966 – The House of Baxter | Doctor Fell
- 1967 – My Three Angels
- 1968 – The Sound of Thunder | Concert Revue
- 1969 – Salad Days | The Bishop’s Candlesticks | The Bathroom Door | The Bald Prima Donna | The Trapper
- 1970 – The Boy Friend
- 1971 – The Road to Skull Hill | Oklahoma Will Any Gentleman?
- 1972 – The Paul Story | Calamity Jane
- 1973 – Quiet Weekend | Show Boat
- 1974 – Salad Days | The Sound of Music
- 1975 – Candied Peel | Jesus Folk | Entertainment ’75 A Revue
- 1976 – Brigadoon | Spirit
- 1977 – Fiddler on the Roof | Sailor Beware
- 1978 – The Pajama Game
- 1979 – Glory
- 1980 – Annie Get Your Gun | Revue ’80 | The Curious Savage
- 1981 – The Music Man
- 1982 – Brush With a Body | Spirit
- 1983 – Breath of Spring | The Golden Legion of Cleaning Women | Carousel
- 1984 – The Odyssey of Runyan Jones | The Valiant | The Dear Departed | The Mikado
- 1985 – Fish Out of Water | Charlie Girl
- 1986 – East Lynne | Oklahoma
- 1987 – Oliver | See How They Run
- 1988 – The Dream House | The Sentimental Bloke
- 1989 – Play On | Ruth
- 1990 – Witness for the Prosecution | Half a Sixpence
- 1991 – Oh Clarence! | Guys and Dolls
- 1992 – Any Number Can Die |The Pirates of Penzance
- 1993 – Broadway | Love’s a Luxury | Fiddler on the Roof
- 1994 – Murder on the Nile | The Pearl of Pelagia | South Pacific
- 1995 – Trial by Jury | The Happiest Days of Your Life | Kismet
- 1996 – Arsenic and Old Lace | My Fair Lady
- 1997 – I’ll Leave it to You | HMS Pinafore
- 1998 – Kadooshus | The Farnsdale Avenue…Murder Mystery | Kiss Me, Kate
- 1999 – Only an Orphan Girl | Brigadoon
- 2000 – The Diary of Anne Frank | Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
- 2001 – Murdered to Death | The Mikado
- 2002 – The Blue Goose | Oliver
- 2003 – A Kind of Alaska | The Reading Group | Garlic and Lavender | Bye Bye Birdie
- 2004 – The Importance of Being Earnest | Guys and Dolls
- 2005 – Blithe Spirit | Variety Concert | Li’l Abner
- 2006 – On Golden Pond | 50th Anniversary Concert | Les Misérables
- 2007 – Bottles With Baskets On | Shadows | A Cut in the Rates | The Pirates of Penzance
- 2008 – Over the River and Through the Woods | Variety Concert | Seussical
- 2009 – Curious Savage | Man of La Mancha
- 2010 – Hat Trick: 3 Australian Plays | The Music Man
- 2011 – Lord Arthur Saville’s Crime | The Sound of Music
- 2012 – Murder is Announced | HMS Pinafore
- 2013 – Hotel Sorrento | Fiddler on the Roof
- 2014 – Breath of Spring | Jesus Christ Superstar
- 2015 – Almost, Maine | My Fair Lady
- 2016 – Arsenic & Old Lace | 60th Anniversary Concert | Hairspray (CPP 60th Anniversary Year)
- 2017 – Stories in the Dark | Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
- 2018 – Witness for the Prosecution | Beauty and the Beast
- 2019 – Calendar Girls | Anything Goes
- 2020 – Open Mic Night
- 2021 – One Act Plays
- 2022 – Mort | The Addams Family
- 2023 – Sense & Sensibility | Oliver!
- 2024 – Little Women | Hello, Dolly!
